Mr. Bill Gates acknowledges Hester for developing a Newcastle Disease Vaccine - Sonalika Tractors aims to expand in Europe and 5 global markets eyes 20% growth - Schneider Electric Announces EcoXpert™ Master Level Partners in Critical Power - NAREDCO TO LAUNCH ITS FIRST PROPERTY EXHIBITION IN MUMBAI - BSE’s India INX gets SEBI nod for listing framework of debt securities - Prime Minister inaugurates Dr. Ambedkar International Centre - Defending champ Rashpal confident of retaining Crown - ICAI International Conference 2017 Concludes Today - adidas partners with Lifestyle International Pvt. Ltd. adidas women’s apparel will now also be available at 16 Lifestyle stores across India - PUBLICATION OF MARATHI NOVEL "HIS DAY" FOR HIZDE [Trans Gender] RELEASED AT A BOOK LAUNCH AMIDST EUNUNCHS - NSE compiles ‘Regulation wise Compilation of SAT Orders’ Senior SEBI officials release an e-book in 5 volumes on SAT orders - Ruchi Soya to scale up Soybean crushing business post favorable government policies - Cloudnine Group of Hospitals Inaugurates First ever hospital in New Mumbai dedicated to mothers & babies - STERLING HOLIDAYS REDEFINING THE INDIAN HOLIDAY LANDSCAPE - Astron Paper and Board Mill Limited’s IPO opens on December 15, 2017, with Price Band of Rs. 45 to Rs. 50 per Equity Share of Face Value of Rs. 10 each - SumTotal Advances as a Leader in Nucleus Research’s Talent Management Technology Value Matrix for a Third Consecutive Year - PRICING OF USD 500 MILLION 3.835% FIXED RATE SENIOR UNSECURED DOLLAR GREEN BOND OF 10 YEAR TENOR BY INDIAN RAILWAY FINANCE CORPORATION LIMITED - Nation pays tribute to Dr Babasaheb R. Ambedkar on his death anniversary along with the Prime Minister and Celebrity - 2nd Global Textile Technology & Engineering Show 1st – 3rd February 2019 - White Hill Music releases brand new song ‘Nain’ from the album ‘Solo’ - Camlin brings Iconic `Flora Classic’ Pencils back - The 5th Edition of China Homelife / Machinex India 2017 inaugurated at BEC, Mumbai - Emotion with devotion needed for Khadi’s growth, says Minister Giriraj Singh - Union Bank of India ties up with RXIL (Receivable Exchange of India Ltd) as a TReDS (Trade Receivable Discounting System) Partner - CJP Uploads Online Petition Intervening For Peace in Ayodhya - The Governor of Maharashtra CH Vidyasagar Rao has expressed grief on the demise of veteran actor Shashi Kapoor - Actress-Model Daljeet Kaurr Mrs Universe 2016 introduced models from 26 cities for Mr, Miss and Mrs IAWA 2017 at Off the Grid Lounge,Mumbai - Music Launch of ‘Dr. Tatya Lahane | Angaar… Power Is Within’ A Mesmerizing Affair - Noor (Non-Interest Bearing Resident Accounts) Personal Accounts Launched By Federal Bank on Milad-E-Sherif - Latest Patented Innovation from Kaspersky Lab Helps Businesses Tackle Stealth Remote Control - VODAFONE INTRODUCES NOIDA’S FIRST FREE WI-FI ENABLED BUS SHELTER - Intersolar India, the Three Day Flagship Solar Industry Conference and Exhibition Opens on December 5 in Mumbai - Mercedes-Benz strengthens its after-sales footprint in south India, inaugurates the first luxury car workshop in Salem - Ravi Dube, Ahsaan Qureshi,Shharad Malhotra,Meghna Naidu, Iqbal Khan, Ishrat Ali, Daljit Kaur & Yogesh Lakhani came for 4th Dashnik Mumbai Press Media Award at Iskcon,Mumbai. - INAUGURATION OF AADHAR ENROLMENT-CUM-UPDATION CENTRE AT MUMBAI GPO - Hema Malini launches “ONE FOR ALL , ALL FOR ONE”, a Tribute and salute to Indian Army - Bollywood Actor and MP Hema Malini during announcement the Synergy, an Indo Georgian Dance fusion in Mumbai - Glamour Rendezvous Diagold cuts the ribbon with Shilpa Shetty - Moneycontrol hosts a special ground event ‘India’s Road Ahead’ - GUJARAT ELECTIONS STARTS TODAY - Yogacharya Amit Dev transcends Mahaprabhu Ji’s Yoga to Russia

Karnataka High Court: Qnet case is where criminal legislations are not even remotely applicable

screenshot_20170101_234322

Mumbai, 24 February, 2017 (GPN) : In a landmark judgment that will change the way Direct Selling and Multi-level marketing companies are perceived, the Karnataka High Court has quashed all allegations made against QNet’s Malaysia based executive. Pronouncing the judgement in a case filed against Naresh Balasubramaniam the honourable High Court has made some very strong and relevant observations that are likely to clear the air around the business model of QNet that has been going through harried times, thanks to completely misconstrued facts about its business model.

 

Naresh Balasubramaniam a resident of Kuala Lumpur had approached the High Court for a case against him by the Cyber Crime Police (Economic Offences Division) on a complaint filed by one Ms Pragya a resident of Electronic City.

 

Pronouncing the judgment the Honourable HC clearly stated that there is no case where any over act in inducing the complainant from parting with any money or influencing her in doing so was observed. Only because Subramaniam was the Managing Consultant of Q-Net India did not in any way provide grounds for his name to be included in the charge sheet said the order.

 

“It is not shown that the petitioner is associated with the latter. This circumstance alone would render the proceedings initiated against the petitioner had in law” read the order. Another significant factor that went in favour of Subramaniam is that he is a resident of Malaysia in the Charge sheet, “that is yet another factor that would dilute the case against the petitioner.” the order read.

 

What is more interesting are the observations that the HC has made on the overall allegations against Q-Net and its sub-franchisee Vihaan. Q–Net, is said to be engaged in multi-level marketing or direct marketing. According to the HC “the police appear to proceed on the basis that the activities of a multi-level marketing company is illegal and arbitrary. There is a suspicion created about the business in some circles while there are others who vouch for it as a sound business model. The doubts and strong words employed by the Bombay High court in denigrating the business itself, is a case in point.”

 

The HC has very clearly stated in no uncertain terms that “it is evident that ‘Direct Selling’ has emerged as a global industry. A report prepared by the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry discloses that direct and multi-level marketing in India is estimated to be to the tune of several hundred crores of rupees. And that it has emerged as an independent industry.”

 

The FICCI report as quoted by the Honourable HC also states that direct selling and multi-level marketing are forms of economic activity that could play  a very important role in a country like India, as it envisages low transactional cost mechanisms  for sale of consumer products without the need for large marketing infrastructure. This is a very important observation as it helps clear the pollution spread by unwanted and probably self-interested elements around the business model of direct selling companies.

 

The HC has held that business models of multi-level marketing companies where the benefit is a result of sale of goods or services for subscribers, is not illegal.

 

As per the HC “Activities of QNet and Vihan i.e., the multilevel marketing companies, do not constitute offences under the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978.” According to the judgement, the activities of the company do not fall within the definition of ‘Money Circulations Scheme’ under Section 2(c) of the act, nor does it fall within the definition of ‘Prize chit’ under Section 2(e) of the Act.

 

Concluding on the applicability of the Act, the HC observed that “when the activities of these companies do not constitute either Money Circulation Scheme or Prize Chit, the offences under Sections 4 and 5 of the Act, do not even remotely apply to such activities and consequently charging the accused for such offences is unsustainable.”

 

Quoting the FICCI report the HC has observed that “absence of a clear legislation and regulatory framework for multilevel marketing companies, have led to severe problems for such companies operating in the country. Legislation such as the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978, which do not even remotely apply to the activities of multilevel marketing companies, are applied by the investigating authorities leading to disastrous results.”

 

There is no way that criminal prosecution can be initiated under the provisions of the IPC and the best possible course of action would be to initiate proceedings under the Consumer Protection Act, 1886 in cases which have been filed against Q-Net or its stakeholders.

 

Cases registered in the Q-Net case are typically those where criminal legislation which are not even remotely applicable to the circumstances of the case have been invoked to substantiate the charges. “The dispute, if at all, is between a consumer and a direct seller and ought to be adjudicated under the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.” says the HC.

All this puts to rest the misconceptions spread around the direct selling business models of companies like Q-Net and will go a long way in clearing a path of sustainable growth for the sector and all those associated with it. 

OFFICIAL QUOTE FROM Q-NET: media.india@qnet.net 

“This is a step in the right direction and we are happy to see that justice has been served and elated that the honourable court has recognised the importance of the direct selling industry to the economy” says Raj Vasudevan, Chief Legal Officer of Q-Net.

 

About the Author

Sachin Murdeshwar
Sachin Murdeshwar is a Sr.Journalist and Columnist in several Mainline Newspapers and Portals.He is an ardent traveller and likes to explore destinations to the core.

Be the first to comment on "Karnataka High Court: Qnet case is where criminal legislations are not even remotely applicable"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*